Saturday, July 21, 2012

Post-Fukushima anti-Nuclear Activism in Japan

Despite all evidence to the contrary, a persistent stereotype about "East Asians" is their alleged lack of interest in social and political activism. While it is true that decades of affluence in Japan and more recently South Korea has contributed to hyper-consumerism at the expense of meaningful social engagement particularly by the youth, one should not forget the sustained student activism on elite South Korean campuses throughout its years of authoritarian rule. At the height of the Vietnam War, the security arrangement between the United States and Japan triggered off massive waves of enduring protests that radicalized an entire Japanese generation.

The social and political quietism the appeared to have set in during the post-Vietnam era of prosperity in Japan, driven by a dominant ideology that the state and corporations can be trusted has been rudely shattered the Fukushima catastrophe. Of course social activism around many important issues such as the environment and women's rights had never been extinguished. However, by and large, engagement with such important social issues was limited to a relatively small section of the general Japanese population. More often than not, the general population whose lives were devoted to the corporations or the state, had no time for such activism. The Fukushima nuclear disaster however, has galvanized a very large and diverse cross-section of the population. The evidence of organized cover-ups in the nuclear industry has contributed to the rapid evaporation of trust in corporations and the state.

After the post-Fukushima suspension of all nuclear reactors, the recent decision to re-start the reactors at Ohi has triggered off a tsunami of protests in Tokyo. At the anti-nuclear rally last Monday, over 170,000 activists from all walks of life demonstrated outside the Prime Minister Noda Yokohiko's residence in the heart of Tokyo. The Nobel Laureate in Literature Oe Kenzaburo as well as the prominent composer Sakamoto Ruichi were there. More importantly, "salarymen" or the corporate employees who might be expected be disdainful of such behaviours, were part of the massive demonstration. There were also tens of thousands of "furita"" or the part-time workers who have rejected the mortgaging of one's life to corporations. The presence of the part-time workers in significant numbers was significant, particularly as they perceived by the wider population as socially disengaged and shirkers. There were of course thousands of grandparents, housewives and children.

Decades of complacency and misplaced trust in authority and expertise has been sharply eroded by these anti-nuclear activists from all sections of Japanese society. Civil society activism and engagement by people demanding a say in policies that affect their lives has been re-ignited by the Fukushima catastrophe. The nuclear issue however is obviously not restricted to Japan. Locked into the same game of global neo-liberal capitalism, China and India are also dramatically increasing their lethal dependence on nuclear energy.



Thursday, July 19, 2012

A Letter on the killings in Chattisgarh, the Times of India


This appeared as a letter to the editor, TOI, 19 July.

Jairam Ramesh’s statements as far as they refer to the Bijapur killings in his interview (July 16, 2012) are unacceptable and diversionary, apart from being factually incorrect. Since 2005 activists have been condemning the use of teenagers on both sides of the State-Maoist war. In any case, there is a clear difference between Maoist child soldiers drafted as combatants, and non-combatant children attending a meeting in their own village to discuss sowing. If even senior ministers chose to ignore this basic difference underlying the Geneva conventions, what can we expect from forces on the ground?

Even if the CRPF committed a genuine mistake, what is inexcusable is the cover up that first resulted in the proud claim to have killed Maoists, and then moved on to talk about human shields, and the criminal records of those killed. It is not as if the CRPF checked people’s criminal records before firing at them! And how does attending a village meeting – even if Maoists are present - make you into a human shield? One expects the Government, and its Ministers to ensure this never happens again, rather than obfuscate a deadly attack on unarmed civilians.

It has become fashionable to attack civil rights activists as if demanding the rule of law were equivalent to wielding a gun. Despite repeated efforts by activists to work with government to find a peaceful and just solution to the ongoing conflicts and problems in different parts of the country, the Government seems to have decided to wage a war those who stand for the constitutional, democratic and human rights of all citizens, as part of its strategy of media management and manufacturing consent.

Aruna Roy, Nandini Sundar, Bela Bhatia, Apoorvanand, Harsh Mander, Nikhil Dey, Kavita Srivastava, Sandeep Pandey, Shabnam Hashmi, Kiran Bhatty, Himanshu Kumar, Harsh Dhobhal, S.R. Darapuri, Arundhati Dhuru


Water Crisis in India

The water crisis in India continues. Officially, about 60% of the population have access to running water. However, practically all the water is heavily contaminated with heavy metals - courtesy of the effluents from unregulated industries and general waste. Arsenic is a common contaminant in many parts of the country and just a few weeks ago, there was news that water in some regions of Punjab is contaminated with uranium. If heavy metals, arsenic and radioactivity were not enough, over 65% of the population has no access to toilets and defecation in the open is common, even in the wooded areas of New Delhi. The bacteria laced water is a major contributor to easily avoidable killer outbreaks of gastro-enteritis, diarrhoea and dysentery. Although the Indian parliament, goaded by the media coverage of the situation, discussed the issue, in the rush to maintain the mythical 8% growth, it is unlikely that any action, substantive or merely decorative, will be taken. Meanwhile, the construction of mega shopping malls that consume huge supplies of water and electricity, continues. This summer, many malls of New Delhi ran out of water and required multiple water-tankers to keep the washrooms and the restaurants operational. Predictably, in some quarters, the late arrival of the monsoons, not the hyper-manic production and consumption cycles connected to global capitalism and obsession with the 8% growth target was blamed for the water shortage. The mirage of even more economic growth and consumption via foreign direct investments in the retail sector continue to be touted by influential New Delhi policy wonks as the solution for the current crisis!

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

The Chattisgarh killings, India, 28th June, 2012

On the night of 28th June, 2012, at least 19 adivasis, five of whom were children in the 12-15 years age-group were gunned down in Bijapur district of Chattisgarh. The Union Home Minister, Mr. K. Chidambaram initially announced that among those killed were major Maoists and he offered some names. Later, he admitted that the names supplied to him by the state government did not match with those who were killed. In response to the fact that at least five children were killed, the Chief Minister predictably claimed that the Maoists use children as "human shields". Outrage was expressed in most mainstream media outlets. The July 18th issue of Outlook had a cover story titled "How can Chidambaram sleep well at night"? The killings reminded Swami Agnivesh of the Jallianwalabagh massacre and former President of the People's Union for Civil Liberties, Justice Rajinder Sachar called for an independent inquiry. 


A three member team comprising of J. P. Rao, Kopa Kunjam and  Nandini Sundar, Professor of Sociology at Delhi University, visited the site of the killings and met with families of the victims almost immediately after the tragic events. Their important report together with the response of the families of the victims,  is appended below. 




MONDAY, JULY 9, 2012


Kottaguda-Rajpenta-Sarkeguda massacre


A three member team, consisting of JP Rao, Kopa Kunjam and Nandini Sundar visited Kottaguda, Sarkeguda and Rajpenta villages on 3rd and 4th July 2012.



The three villages merge into each other and have been carved up in an arbitrary fashion between different panchayats (Korsaguda and Chipurbhatti panchayats). The field where the firing took place is an open area surrounded by houses, some of which are in Kottaguda and some of which fall in Rajpenta. The villagers had returned only in 2009 after Salwa Judum had burnt their village in 2005, and are still struggling to put their cattle together and rebuild all houses properly. The meeting on the 28th night was held to discuss how to help those without cattle and single women headed households, and also to plan the holding of the bija pondum (seed sowing festival). The three villages share a common earth shrine – which means they celebrate all their festivals together. 


The villagers say that there were no Maoists present, and that the police were most likely injured in cross-firing. The absence of any Maoist leaders is supported by the fact that had there been a squad in the village, there would have been sentries posted in the direction of Basaguda thana.
Whatever the CRPF’s claims, what is indisputable is that they knew they were in the middle of a village and yet did not use night flares or observe even the most basic precautions when firing. In all 17 persons have been killed, of which 7 are minors; 9 have been injured, and at least 5 women have been beaten/assaulted. One cow has died and one bull has been injured, and there are bullet marks on the houses.  Two people were killed by Salwa Judum and security forces in 2005, and almost all the houses in all three villages were burnt.


What is shocking is not just the massacre itself but the cover up that followed with the CRPF and Home Minister claiming that they had shot top Naxal leaders, when they could clearly see that they had killed villagers including small children, since 16 of the bodies were sent back that night. The CRPF version also does not explain why one person was killed in the morning.
We met Mr. Kuruvanshi, the SDM appointed to investigate the incident. He seemed amused at our visit, and asked why the villagers were meeting at night. When asked, he also said he had no plans to visit the village, and if the villagers wished, they could come and see him. Subsequently, the villagers have been summoned to his office on the 9th of July.   
We are enclosing a statement signed by family members of each of the deceased, three of the girls beaten/molested and other witnesses from the village.
JP Rao, Kopa Kunjam, Nandini Sundar
4th July 2012
Village Kottaguda, Thana Basaguda, Zilla Bijapur








Statement by families of victims
            
On 28th June 2012, we were having a meeting in Kottaguda of three villages – Rajpenta, Kottaguda and Sarkeguda – to discuss the upcoming seed sowing festival and also how to help those families without cattle and those households headed by widows. Since we were busy ploughing and repairing our houses during the day, we decided to have the meeting in the evening. We three villages share a common earth shrine.
            
The meeting started around 8 pm. Around 9-10 pm, the CRPF, SPOs and police came and surrounded us from all sides and started firing without warning. It lasted one hour. Sixteen people were shot and killed at night and also axed. Their bodies were taken away at night. The force camped in the grounds all night. Three girls who were taking shelter in a house at the edge of the meeting ground were pulled out, their hair pulled, beaten and assaulted and threatened with rape. 5 injured persons were also taken away at night. Madkam Shanti and Kaka Sarika were also beaten.
            
In the morning, Irpa Munna s/o Raju, age 27 approximately was killed when he came out of his house. When he did not fully die he was bludgeoned to death with bricks. His body was taken away in the morning along with two more injured.Irpa Dinesh s/o Raju who has four small children was shown as a Naxalite commander, Somlu, from Korsaguda. His body was not returned to the village.
            
They also stole Rs. 2000 from Madkam Nagesh’s house, Rs. 5000 from Irpa Raju’s house and Rs. 30,000 from Irpa Narayan’s house. They also took Madkam Dilip’s mobile and Apka Meetu’s cycle. In the morning we all villagers went to the Basaguda thana but we were not allowed in; nor did any police come out. They had taken the injured and also arrested some 25 others. The bodies, except for Irpa Dinesh’s, were returned on 29th evening and we cremated them the next day. Dinesh’s body is buried in the PS.
            
Our villages have suffered terribly under Salwa Judum. All 30 houses were burnt in Kottaguda in 2005, 10 out of 12 houses were burnt in Rajpenta, and 27 out of 30 houses were burnt in Sarkeguda. Two people were killed by Salwa Judum and police. Korsa Bhima s/o Korsa Dora, age 15 was taken from Sarkeguda village in 2005 and killed in the thana. Madkam Balla, s/o Dula, age 35, was killed in Basaguda thana when he had gone to buy nails for house building. There has been no FIR and no compensation. We all ran away to Andhra Pradesh and returned in 2009.
            
We were just getting back to normal life when the CRPF attacked us again.




The following persons were killed (ages are approximate):
Kottaguda
1.      Kaka Saraswati, d/o Kaka Rama, age 12
2.      Kaka Samaiyya, s/o Kaka Dula, age 33 (Voter ID card)
3.      Kaka Ravul (Rahul) s/o Narayan, 10th class student, age 16
4.      Ram Vilas Madkam, s/o Madkam Buchaiya, 10th class student, age 16

Rajpenta
5.      Madkam Nagesh, s/o Malla, age 35 (Voter ID card)
6.      Madkam Suresh, s/o Malla, age 25 (brother of Nagesh)
7.      Irpa Munna s/o Raju, age 27 (aka as Ramesh)
8.      Irpa Dinesh s/o Raju, age 20-22 (brother of Munna, father of 4 children)
9.      Irpa Narayan s/o Mutta, age 52 (Voter ID card)
10.   Irpa Dharmaiyya s/o Bhima, age 40-45
11.   Irpa Suresh, s/o Chandraiyya age 10
12.   Madkam Dilip s/o Mutta, age 17

Sarkeguda
13.   Sarke Ramanna s/o Potti, age 25
14.   Apka Mutta s/o Sukram, age 16
15.   Madvi Aitu s/o Bhima, age 35-40
16.   Kunjam Malla s/o Urra, age 12-15
17.   Korsa Bichem s/o Gotta, age 20

The following people were injured and taken away by the forces
Sarkeguda
  1. Korsa Raju s/o Bhima, age 21-25
  2. Sarke Pullaya s/o Kistayya, age 22 (not taken to hospital, doing herbal remedies in village)
  3. Apka Chotu s/o Bhima, age 14-18

Kottaguda
  1. Madkam Soma s/o Bhima, age 29/30
  2. Kaka Shenti s/o Lacha, age 19
  3. Irpa Chinakka, w/o Irpa Narsa, age 40
  4. Kaka Ramesh s/o Kistaiyya, age 10-12
  5. Kaka Parvati d/o Kistaiyya, age 9-10
  6. Irpa Munna s/o Lacha age 25 (doing herbal remedies at home, not taken by forces)

Girls beaten and molested
Kottaguda
  1. Sruti Barse d/o Subbarao, age 15
  2. Irpa Pushpa d/o Dharmaiyya, age 16
  3. Irpa Lalita, d/o Rama, age 17-18
(These 3 girls were pulled out of Lalita’s house, threatened with rape and beaten)
  1. Kaka Sarika d/o Kaka Kama, age 16 (Sarika and her aunt Karam Dare were running and pulled to the ground by a CRPF man. Later they were beaten and taken where all the villagers had been assembled by the forces, before they were taken to thana)
  2. Madkam Shanti w/o Madkam Balla, age 30 (She was beaten while running)
 (Sruti, Sarika and Madkam Shanti have all signed this statement)
Please give us justice. We are also citizens of this country.
Signed by family members of all deceased and others in village


4th July 2012

Testimony on Killing of Madkam Balla
My husband Madkam Balla was killed in 2005 when he had gone to Basaguda to buy nails, and from there he went to Lingagiri. He was killed there by the police – he was shot in the back while running – and his body was taken to the thana. His body was returned to the village after it rotted, after 6 days. There was no FIR and no compensation.
Please give me justice. I have six children.
I was also beaten on 28th night when CRPF killed 17 people from our villages.

Sd.
Madkam Shanti, w/o Madkam Balla, Kottaguda
http://nandinisundar.blogspot.ca/2012/07/kottaguda-rajpenta-sarkeguda-massacre.html







Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Indian anti-nuclear activists subjected to psychiatric treatment


Over the past few months, particularly after the Fukushima catastrophe, the movement against the Koodankulam nuclear reactor in India has intensified. So has the vilification of the anti-nuclear movement. While nobody is too surprised at the public relations efforts of the Indian nuclear establishment, the recent attempt to label the anti-nuclear activists as suffering from schizophrenia and paranoia surely borders on the bizarre. The state-run National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences has been roped in to provide psychiatrist counselling to the nuclear activists and some psychiatrists at the institution have claimed that their job it is to make people "understand the importance of the nuclear power plant." 

Read all about it in this insightful piece by Praful Bidwai:

http://nuclear-news.info/2012/06/24/indian-government-treating-anti-nuclear-activists-as-psychiatric-cases/

NIMHANS psychiatrists, to their shame, are striving to help people ”understand the importance of the nuclear power plant.” They treat opposition to nuclear power as a disorder like schizophrenia, paranoia, or craving for victimhood.
Demonising anti-nuclear protests, The Daily Star, Praful Bidwai, 15 June 12, So monumen-tally arrogant is India’s nuclear establishment that it brazenly brands its critics insane and in need of psychiatric treatment. It has asked the state-run National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences (NIMHANS) to “counsel” the tens of thousands protesting against the Koodankulam nuclear power station in Tamil Nadu that it’s perfectly safe.
This marks a new offensive to impose nuclear power upon people who have resisted Koodankulam’s Russian-made reactors since 1988. After Fukushima, the presumption that fears about nuclear hazards are irrational betrays delusional insensitivity.
The police have filed 107 First Information Reports against an incredible 55,795 people in Koodankulam, charging 6,800 of them with ”sedition” and “waging war.” This sets a new record in harassment of popular protests anywhere. Leave alone sedition, there hasn’t been one violent incident during the seven-months-long Koodankulam protests.
NIMHANS psychiatrists, to their shame, are striving to help people ”understand the importance of the nuclear power plant.” They treat opposition to nuclear power as a disorder like schizophrenia, paranoia, or craving for victimhood.
By their criteria, more than 80% of the population of Japan, Germany,
France and Russia, which opposes new nuclear plants, must be
considered insane. As an academic research institution, NIMHANS
shouldn’t act as a nuclear propaganda agency.
NIMHANS seems to have taken its cue from Prime Minister Manmohan
Singh, who attributed the protests to the “foreign hand.” But the real
“foreign hand” is Singh himself, who is hitching India’s energy
trajectory to imported reactors, including French reactors at Jaitapur
(Maharashtra), and American reactors at Mithi Virdi (Gujarat) and
Kovvada (Andhra).
After Fukushima, nuclear safety can no longer be analysed from the
usual “expert” probabilistic perspective. As the official German
Ethics Commission on safe energy says, Fukushima has decisively
changed nuclear risk perceptions: “More people have come to
realise…that major accidents can indeed occur.” As physicist Alvin
Weinberg said: “A nuclear accident anywhere is a nuclear accident
everywhere.”
Fukushima occurred in an industrially advanced country, still hasn’t
been brought under control, and exposes flaws in the global nuclear
industry’s technological risk-assessment methods. Says the Ethics
Commission: Fukushima “has shaken people’s confidence … [They] are no
longer prepared to leave it to … experts to decide how to deal with…
the possibility of an uncontrollable… accident.”
This applies to India too. Its Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) has a
poor safety culture and record. DAE parrots clichés about the Russian
reactors’ safety. But it doesn”t even have full access to their
design.
It’s the DAE and Nuclear Power Corporation, not the protesters, who
are delusion-prone. When the Fukushima crisis decisively turned for
the worse with hydrogen explosions, DAE secretary Sreekumar Banerjee
said these were “purely a chemical reaction and not a nuclear
emergency …..
http://www.thedailystar.net/newDesign/news-details.php?nid=238299